Political Science (Democratic Politics-II) | Chapter – 5

Outcomes of Democracy

1. Introduction

Democracy is considered better than other forms of government. But how do we assess its outcomes? We should judge democracy not by what we wish it would do, but by what it can reasonably achieve. Democracy is only a form of government; it creates conditions for achieving goals, but citizens have to take advantage of those conditions.

2. Why Democracy is Better

  • Promotes equality among citizens.
  • Enhances the dignity of the individual.
  • Improves the quality of decision-making.
  • Provides a method to resolve conflicts.
  • Allows room to correct mistakes.

3. Accountable, Responsive and Legitimate Government

  • Democracy produces a government that is accountable to the citizens and responsive to their needs and expectations.
  • Decisions in a democracy may take more time, because of deliberation and negotiation. But they are more acceptable and more effective. The cost of time is worth it.
  • Democracy ensures that decisions are taken according to rules and procedures (transparency). Every citizen has the right and the means to examine the process of decision-making. The Right to Information Act (2005) is an example.
  • Democracies have regular, free and fair elections; open public debate on major policies; and citizens’ right to information about the government.
  • Democratic governments do not always succeed: they sometimes ignore people’s demands, and corruption is common. But a democratic government is a legitimate government: it is the people’s own government. Support for democracy is overwhelming across the world.

4. Economic Growth and Development

  • Looking at studies of countries over a long period, dictatorships have had a slightly higher rate of economic growth on average. But the difference is small, and economic development depends on many factors: population size, global situation, cooperation from other countries, and the economic priorities of the country.
  • Democracy is not a guarantee of economic development, but we cannot say that democracy is a recipe for poverty. We should prefer democracy because it has several other positive outcomes.

5. Reduction of Inequality and Poverty

  • Democracies are based on political equality: every citizen has one vote with equal weight.
  • However, economic inequalities have grown in many democracies. A small number of ultra-rich people enjoy a highly disproportionate share of wealth and income, while those at the bottom have very little.
  • Poor voters form a large part of the electorate, and no party wants to lose their votes. Yet democratically elected governments have not addressed poverty as much as expected. In some countries, like Bangladesh, a large portion of the population still lives in poverty.

6. Accommodation of Social Diversity

  • Democracies usually develop a procedure to conduct their competition, which reduces the possibility of tensions becoming explosive or violent. No society can fully and permanently resolve conflicts among groups, but democracy helps us respect differences and negotiate.
  • Democracy is not simply rule by majority opinion. The majority must work with the minority so that the government represents the general view.
  • Rule by majority must not become rule by a majority community based on religion, race or language. Every citizen should have a chance to be in the majority at some point of time. If someone is barred from being in the majority because of birth, democracy ceases to be accommodative.
  • Belgium accommodated its diversity well; Sri Lanka’s experience showed the dangers of majoritarianism.

7. Dignity and Freedom of Citizens

  • Democracy promotes dignity and freedom of the individual better than any other form of government.
  • Dignity of women: most societies were male-dominated. Long struggles of women have created sensitivity that respect and equal treatment of women are necessary for a democratic society. Women still face discrimination, but they now have the legal and moral basis to fight it.
  • Caste inequality: democracy has strengthened the claims of disadvantaged and discriminated castes for equal status and opportunity. Instances of caste-based discrimination still happen, but they lack legal and moral foundations.
  • The fact that people complain about democracy is itself proof of its success: people have become aware of their rights and expect more. A public expression of dissatisfaction shows that people are no longer subjects but citizens.

8. Important Questions

Q1. How does democracy produce an accountable government?
Ans. Through regular, free and fair elections, open debate on policies, and citizens’ right to information about government decisions.

Q2. Why is democracy called a legitimate government?
Ans. Because it is the people’s own government, elected by them and answerable to them.

Q3. “Democracy is not simply rule by majority opinion.” Explain.
Ans. The majority must work with the minority, and every citizen should have a chance to be in the majority at some time; majority rule must not become rule by one community.

Q4. Why is economic growth not the only test of democracy?
Ans. Growth depends on many factors other than the form of government; democracy has other important outcomes like dignity, freedom and accountability.

Q5 (long). How does democracy accommodate social diversity? Explain with examples.
Ans. Democracies develop procedures for peaceful competition among groups, which reduce conflicts. In a democracy, the majority works with the minority, and the government represents the general view. Every citizen can be part of the majority on some issue; no group is permanently excluded because of birth. Belgium, for example, changed its Constitution to share power equally between Dutch and French speakers, avoiding civil war. In India too, linguistic states, reservations and federalism have helped accommodate different groups.

9. Conclusion

Democracy does not solve every problem, but it is better than other forms of government in giving accountable, legitimate governments, accommodating diversity, and promoting the dignity and freedom of citizens. Its outcomes depend on how citizens use the opportunities it provides.